Alexi's Greek Cafe

3863 Fifth Ave, San Diego, CA 92103, United States
+1 619-297-1777
$$$ Greek restaurant , Cafe , Gyro restaurant
(645 Reviews)
Price Range $10–20

Alexi's Greek Cafe is a longtime staple tucked into a modest corner of San Diego’s Hillcrest neighborhood, offering a grounded Greek dining experience that feels like a steady favorite rather than a trend-driven spot. Operating out of an older building that hasn’t changed much over the years, the cafe exudes a straightforward, no-frills charm where the focus remains firmly on hearty, authentic food and familiar service.

This is the kind of place you come to when you want satisfying Greek classics without fuss or pretension. The menu centers around traditional dishes—think gyro plates, moussaka, spanakopita, and combos that pile on generous servings of meats, dips, and salads. Portions lean toward the generous side, making it good value for anyone seeking a filling meal without the downtown price hike. Lunch often draws locals looking for substantial midday meals that are both affordable and reliably tasty, especially options like their gyro lunch specials and Mediterranean platters.

The atmosphere is casual and welcoming, with a cozy interior where long-running owners and staff maintain a steady rhythm that comes across as friendly and familiar rather than flashy or overly polished. It feels like a neighborhood place where regulars and newcomers alike are greeted warmly and served quickly. The pace suits those stopping by for a relaxed but unhurried meal, whether solo, with friends, or family. Weekdays around lunch tend to be prime times to visit if you want to experience the lively, communal buzz without needing a reservation.

Visitors who appreciate straightforward Greek cafe fare—especially gyro enthusiasts and those hankering for traditional Mediterranean sides like dolmades, saganaki, and tzatziki—will find a dependable spot here. Vegetarians also have solid options like falafel, hummus, and spanakopita, making it inclusive for various dietary preferences without stepping outside the classic Greek palette.

In a neighborhood packed with newer and sometimes pricier options, Alexi's holds steady as an accessible, honest piece of San Diego’s dining fabric, where the food hits familiar notes and the service is consistently friendly. It’s less about dining theatrics and more about revisiting a Greek diner atmosphere that hasn’t forgotten its roots, making it a comfortable stop for those who appreciate tradition and a genuine neighborhood vibe.

Popular for
Popular for lunch
Popular for dinner
Good for solo dining
What they serve
Serves alcohol
Serves beer
Serves coffee
Serves comfort food
Serves healthy options
Quick bite
Serves small plates
Serves vegan dishes
Serves vegetarian dishes
Best for
Serves lunch
Serves dinner
Serves dessert
Accessibility
Has wheelchair-accessible car park
Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
Has wheelchair-accessible seating
Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
Parking
Paid street parking
Somewhat difficult to find a space

Openings Hours

Checking

Monday

11:00 AM - 8:30 PM

Tuesday

11:00 AM - 8:30 PM

Wednesday

11:00 AM - 8:30 PM

Thursday

11:00 AM - 8:30 PM

Friday

11:00 AM - 8:30 PM

Saturday

11:00 AM - 8:30 PM

Sunday

11:00 AM - 8:30 PM

645 Reviews
Eric Kichty

13 Dec 2025

Such a great place, great food, great service. A gem in the midst of all the expensive madness. Great food anywhere any price. But the price here even makes it more of special meal. Lunch specials that make it affordable to eat out. Consistently great all the time and with a smile. Thank you for feeding us!

Dennis Pixler

30 Nov 2025

Alexis Greek restaurant up town at 3863 5th avenue. My wife and wardered in one day while looking for new restaurants to try out. We ordered a Greek salad and two Gyros for lunch. The plates are prepared by two men who have been running the place for 28 years. Reservations we have never needed and I doubt they take. It is and older building that has not changed much over the years. The service is fast, the food is excellent, and the staff are usually busy but very friendly. I hate to give away this diamond in the rough but fair is fair. Everyone who wanders in like we did 8 years ago keeps coming back as we do.

Christopher Gorrie

23 Nov 2025

I’ve been coming to Alexi’s for years—honestly close to a decade by now. I came most recently last night, and I hadn’t been in quite a while. Everything was as I remembered. The owner is extremely friendly. The food is classic Greek cafe/diner food. My friend and I ordered a gyro pita sandwich, a small Greek salad, and a chicken kabob with a side of tzatziki. Everything was awesome! The meats were seasoned and flavorful, the salad super fresh, and the tzatziki was incredibly well-crafted. This is a low-key, no-frills Greek joint in the heart of an overly gentrified area, but it holds its own and has for years. The interior isn’t going to wow you, but it will transport you back to the 90s and make you feel like you’re at home and welcome. Definitely come by and try out some of the items! The baklava is really good here as well.

Stephanie Pyle

05 Nov 2025

Amazing Greek food and incredible lunch prices. Definitely try the falafel, best I’ve found in San Diego. Owner is very kind and the service is good.

MiiMii De la Torre

07 Oct 2025

Trying to get a home cooked meal + actually afford the meal? I love to support a local spot, + this is the spot you should try if you like Greek food. Generous portions at extremely affordable prices. Alexi deserves way more praise than he receives. To get such a good meal in this economy deserves accolades. ????????

Lauren

03 Oct 2025

Love Alexi and his food!!! Great prices and great food quality. Service is awesome.

George Abraira Jr

01 Oct 2025

The salad was incredibly delicious, the gyro plate delicious as well. Great always.cozy atmosphere. Located across from Buffalo Exchange, don't miss that as well.

Nayeong Lee

22 Sep 2025

I was drawn in by the mysterious blue lights, and I’m so glad I walked in! The owner was so sweet, and the food was delicious and really affordable. It’s amazing that they’re able to keep such great prices. Highly recommended!

Join the Alexi's Greek Cafe Newsletter

Get the latest updates on seasonal pastries, special events, and local highlights directly in your inbox.